Skip to main content
Move the World.
Tesla Fixed Its Model 3 Brakes with Software – And Showed Us the Future of Cars
Tesla CEO Elon MuskCredit: JD Lasica / Flickr
Tesla CEO Elon Musk
Tesla CEO Elon Musk Credit: JD Lasica / Flickr

Last week, Consumer Reports refused to recommend Tesla's new Model 3 sedan because of "big flaws" with its emergency braking. After extensive testing, CR found that the Model 3 took over 150 feet to brake from 60 mph to a full stop. That is 19 feet longer than what Tesla claimed in its own testing and 21 feet further than comparable new cars. Unsurprisingly, Tesla promised to fix the braking problem—but amazingly, they solved it in a week, with an over-the-air software update. CR now recommends the Model 3, and it marks the first time that a car braking issue has been fixed with code. This dramatically demonstrates how cars are becoming more than mere physical machines.

"Big Flaws": Emergency braking power (how rapidly you can slow down and the distance it takes to stop) is a huge metric for car safety. Bigger cars have more mass and therefore typically take longer to stop. But CR found that the compact electric sedan took 25 feet longer to stop than Tesla's own SUV, the Model X, about 7 feet more than a full-sized Ford F-150, and 21 feet more than the industry average for comparable sedans. CR hunted down an existing Model 3 owner who let them borrow his car to make sure it wasn't just a problem with their test vehicle, and they found the same issue was affecting Model 3s on the road now.

Worse than "Not Great": This did not mean that Model 3s were more dangerous than cars on the road now, even if they didn't stack up to other new cars—150 feet isn't a catastrophe, even if it takes getting used to. More importantly, the braking was inconsistent. In CR's first test, they recorded 130 feet, much like Tesla's house testing, but all subsequent results were much longer. Comparing their findings to Car and Driver's tests, they discovered a "bizarre amount of variation" in Model 3s. One test from 70 mph took "an interminable 196 feet" to stop—two-thirds of a football field. This kind of variation is a bigger flaw than consistently underwhelming performance, because drivers (and Tesla's "Autopilot" driver assistance program) may not be able to accurately predict how the car will behave.

Tesla's Model 3 electric vehicle.
Tesla's Model 3 electric vehicle. Credit: Carlquinn / Wikimedia

3-Alarm Emergency: For a new luxury car (albeit one marketed to a mass audience), failing to get a CR recommendation is a big deal. Failing for a safety issue could be a debacle, and Tesla cannot afford more Model 3-related or safety-related PR problems. Plagued by delays and production problems, and coming on the heels of a couple of high-profile Autopilot crashes, Elon Musk was motivated to get to the bottom of this and solve it quickly. He spoke at length with CR's director of auto testing, and Tesla engineers worked overtime to isolate the issue.

I've been at CR for 19 years and tested more than 1,000 cars, and I've never seen a car that could improve its track performance with an over-the-air update.

Jake Fisher , Director of Auto Testing, Consumer Reports

"Unheard Of" Improvement: The variation provided a clue that the issue was not mechanical—Model 3s could stop around 130 feet, but sometimes they took much longer. After a few days of testing, Musk told CR that the engineers believed the issue was caused by a "calibration issue with the braking control system." Tesla coded a software patch and pushed it out over-the-air. CR tested the Model 3 again, and, as promised, braking distance was consistently shortened by 20 feet. CR says improving basic car functionality, like braking, with a remote update is "unheard of" and "an industry first."

"Cars" as Operating Systems: While they've never done anything as impressive as altering basic car function, this isn't the first time Tesla has made major improvements to its vehicles with a remote update. In 2016, CR found that Teslas' "summon" mode could be triggered accidently, causing the self-parking program to crash into things, but Tesla rapidly pushed out a fix. In early 2017, Tesla remotely installed "automatic emergency braking" on Model S and Model X vehicles out on the road. And last September, during Hurricane Irma, Tesla sent out an update that unlocked extra battery power and increased the range of the electric cars in the path of the storm. Eventually, Tesla hopes to send out the mother of all car upgrades and turn all of its existing fleet into fully self-driving cars. The software isn't quite there yet, but they've been building the hardware they think they'll need to make it work into all of their cars so, one day, they'll be ready for turn-key automation.

More About

Global Health
Can Mosquito-Repellent Clothes Stop the Deadliest Animal on Earth?
Can Mosquito-Repellent Clothes Stop the Deadliest Animal on Earth?
Global Health
Can Mosquito-Repellent Clothes Stop the Deadliest Animal on Earth?
The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse are War, Death, Famine, and Pestilence — what Revelation doesn't tell you is that…
By B. David Zarley

The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse are War, Death, Famine, and Pestilence — what Revelation doesn't tell you is that this last rider sits atop not a horse but a mosquito. The bane of your summer evenings is, in much of the world, a dangerous disease vector; mosquito borne diseases kill hundreds of thousands (and infect hundreds of millions) every year. Mosquitoes carry such dreaded diseases as malaria, yellow fever,…

Global Impact
Could We End Earthquake Deaths?
Could We End Earthquake Deaths?
Watch Now
Global Impact
Could We End Earthquake Deaths?
Thousands die in earthquakes every year - even though we know how to build safely. This engineer is working with people in the most vulnerable places to figure out why.
Watch Now

Earthquakes and hurricanes kill thousands of people a year - but they don't have to. Elizabeth Hausler, founder of Build Change, has spent years identifying the barriers to safe housing worldwide. Here, she shares how we can overcome them to create hurricane and earthquake proof buildings. So far, over 330,000 people are living and learning in safer housing and schools because of our work. That means over 60,000 buildings…

Innovation
The Edible Six Pack Ring That's Saving Marine Animals
The Edible Six Pack Ring That's Saving Marine Animals
Watch Now
Innovation
The Edible Six Pack Ring That's Saving Marine Animals
18 billion pounds of plastic are dumped in the ocean every year. This microbrewery created biodegradable six pack rings to help stem the tide.
Watch Now

Saltwater Brewery was a regular microbrewery that made great craft beer - packaged with the usual plastic six pack rings. As fishermen who saw firsthand the amount of plastic pollution in the ocean, though, they felt they needed to make a change to help marine animals. They came up with the idea to create edible six pack rings made of biodegradable materials left over from the brewing process. Now, they’ve…

Challengers
Five Insights: Ryan Petersen on Tackling Problems That Feel Too Big to Fix
Five Insights: Ryan Petersen on Tackling Problems That Feel Too Big to Fix
Challengers
Five Insights: Ryan Petersen on Tackling Problems That Feel Too Big to Fix
Flexport's founder discusses the personal and business side of building an ambitious startup.
By Mike Riggs

Flexport's founder discusses the personal and business side of building an ambitious startup.

Challengers
Five Insights from AltSchool Founder and CEO, Max Ventilla
Five Insights from AltSchool Founder and CEO, Max Ventilla
Challengers
Five Insights from AltSchool Founder and CEO, Max Ventilla
Max Ventilla on why he thinks its time for a new way to educate kids and how his startup could…
By Mike Riggs

Max Ventilla on why he thinks its time for a new way to educate kids and how his startup could be a way to do it.

Challengers
Powering the World With Nuclear
Powering the World With Nuclear
Watch Now
Challengers
Powering the World With Nuclear
Transatomic believes they've figured out a safe, scalable, cost-effective way to power the world with nuclear.
Watch Now

Transatomic is designing a nuclear reactor that can produce a lot more electricity than a conventional reactor, while creating a lot less nuclear waste. But they’ll need to take on a deeply entrenched industry and convince a cautious public that they can safely harness the most powerful energy in the world.

Challengers
An App for Global Trade
An App for Global Trade
Watch Now
Challengers
An App for Global Trade
Flexport thinks bringing trade into the 21st century could improve lives around the globe.
Watch Now

Flexport believes that nothing helps people improve their lives more than the ability to trade with one another. And, yet international shipping is still way too cumbersome. So Flexport built an in app to make it easier. If Flexport succeeds, nearly everything you buy will cost less.

Superhuman
Karen Aiach on Doing the Impossible
Karen Aiach on Doing the Impossible
Watch Now
Superhuman
Karen Aiach on Doing the Impossible
When Karen Aiach decided to quit her finance job in 2005 in order to find a cure for the rare…
Watch Now

When Karen Aiach decided to quit her finance job in 2005 in order to find a cure for the rare genetic disease that was killing her daughter, people told her it was impossible. In a weird way, it was just what Karen needed to hear. Because it meant if she didn’t do it, no one else would. She started with a search. The first thing she learned is that…