Skip to main content
Move the World.
The DNA-Based Diet You’ll Be Hearing About Everywhere

Lead image design by Andrew Brumagen

Diet advice changes with the decades. I remember eating cheeseless pizzas during the "fat-free" fad (thanks, Dad). And I'll never forget my high school cross country team's T-shirts saying "Eat Pasta, Run Fasta."

If we've learned anything from these fads, it isn't how to eat better. It is that there is no one-size-fits-all diet.

Now, a growing field called "nutrigenomics" aims to provide people with personalized lifestyle guidance, based on their DNA. But is this a breakthrough for nutrition science, or just another fad?

The "How to Eat" Formula

Melina Jampolis is a board-certified physician and nutrition specialist. She helps people reach their goals for fitness and body composition by giving tailor-made diet recommendations.

"Nutrition is all about context. We don't eat nutrients, we eat foods."

David Mutch

A few years ago, a 32-year-old vegetarian man came to her seeking advice on how to build muscle and burn fat.

After four months without progress, Jampolis suggested a Nutrigenomix test. Nutrigenomix is one of several dozen companies that offer genetic tests that purport to give insight into personalized, gene-based nutrition.

Much like 23andMe or Ancestry.com, by sending salvia to a lab, people can learn more about their genetic makeup. Some of the gene-based nutrition companies accomplish this by interpreting genetic data downloaded from 23andMe or Ancestry.

The analysis a subject receives is intended to help them learn which foods to eat to switch on or off specific genes. It can help them understand what foods might affect weight loss, immune functions, or their predispositions to disease.

Jampolis says the test results "confirmed her clinical intuition." Even though a plant-based diet is a healthy option, vegetarianism wasn't quite right for this man.

According to the test results, her client had a variation in his genetic sequence making it more challenging to build muscle. At the same time, his metabolic panel indicated that he should have fewer carbohydrates. With that combined information, Jampolis recommended that he eat less protein from beans and more animal protein.

For Jampolis, despite some of the companies' claims, the genetic test isn't a magic "how to eat" formula. She says there are many ways to interpret the results, so it is best used with a healthcare professional's guidance.

"As a practitioner, you're taking (a genetic test) in the context of a patient and bringing in multiple variables," she says.

The Wild West of Nutrigenomics

Nutrigenomix is one of the few nutrigenomics tests that must be administered by a medical professional. The founder, Ahmed El-Sohemy, specifically designed it that way to "restore credibility to the field."

El-Sohemy, also the nutrigenomics chair of the University of Toronto, says nutrition can be "vulnerable to snake oil science," and consumers should be cautious about genetic testing.

"It was a bit of a wild west. There were some shady operators (...) linking their tests to ridiculously overpriced supplements that were not justified. It was really tainting the whole field. So, we established a test based on the robust science and decided to make it available only through healthcare professionals so that they can answer questions and concerns that people have around genetic testing."

In 2008, El-Sohemy discovered that some people's genetics could be causing them to eat more sugar regularly than others. He pinpointed the sugar habit to a variation in the GLUT2 gene — which became known as the "sweet tooth gene."

But El-Sohemy saw nutrigenomics companies extrapolate new meanings from his work — claiming their test for the sweet tooth gene would reveal how a body processes sugar and the optimal sugar intake level.

"That's nonsense. That's not what the study showed," he says, adding other examples of wild claims like genetic tests "for" an anti-inflammatory diet, or low-carb versus low-fat, where "the science just isn't there yet."

Nonetheless, he does believe the field is making progress. When he first launched the Nutrigenomix in 2012, their test only looked at seven genes. By 2018, they were investigating 72.

The Future of Personalized Food

In the past decade, more rigorous scientific research has been published with discoveries related to nutrigenomics. If "the science isn't there yet," when it comes to crafting personal diets from data, it is on its way.

David Mutch leads a nutrigenomics research program at the University of Guelph, studying diet-gene interactions, especially omega-3 dietary fats. He cites El-Sohemy's 2006 study on coffee and heart attack risk (which he did not collaborate on) as a prime example of robust nutrition science.

The study looked at a variant of the gene CYP1A2, which is associated with how well the body metabolizes caffeine. They found that having a particular version of the gene means that the body metabolizes caffeine slowly, and for this group, excessive coffee consumption may increase their risk of heart attacks.

Studies like this, Mutch says, are building a solid foundation for consumer nutrigenomics tests. If a person tests positive for that gene variant, then the recommendation would be to consume no more than two cups of coffee per day instead of the standard advice of a four-cup limit.

Mutch says that precision nutrition is about much more than DNA. It also takes into account gut bacteria (known as the microbiome), proteins, metabolites, etc. That is why he also supports nutrigenomics tests that are interpreted by a healthcare professional.

"Working with dieticians or healthcare practitioners is actually going to be the most efficient way to take that information you're getting and translate it into an actionable dietary plan. That's the challenge with nutrition. Nutrition is all about context. We don't eat nutrients, we eat foods."

The majority of chronic illnesses in the United States, such as hypertension, high cholesterol, obesity, and diabetes, are treated first with diet and exercise. However, research shows that patients are more likely to adhere to care plans tailored to their genetics instead of general dietary advice.

"This is a piece of the puzzle — to better understand ourselves, to better understand what we may or may not want to think about when we're making choices about the foods we're eating or the lifestyle choices we're making," Mutch says.

Maybe someday, to reduce the risk of heart disease, Alzheimer's, or hypertension, doctors will prescribe food as medicine — and know their prescription will stand the tests of time and science.

We'd love to hear from you! If you have a comment about this article or if you have a tip for a future Freethink story, please email us at [email protected]

Up Next

Food
We Don't Have to Eat Insects. But Feeding Them to Animals Could Save the Planet
edible insects
Food
We Don't Have to Eat Insects. But Feeding Them to Animals Could Save the Planet
Edible insects could more than make up for the world's protein deficiency while cleaning up waste and using fewer resources. But we don't have to eat them. We can use them in animal feed instead.

Edible insects could more than make up for the world's protein deficiency while cleaning up waste and using fewer resources. But we don't have to eat them. We can use them in animal feed instead.

Animals
Bomb Detectors Record Rare Pygmy Blue Whales Singing
pygmy blue whales
Animals
Bomb Detectors Record Rare Pygmy Blue Whales Singing
Underwater microphones used to listen for signs of nuclear bomb testing have captured the singing of a population of rare pygmy blue whales.

Underwater microphones used to listen for signs of nuclear bomb testing have captured the singing of a population of rare pygmy blue whales.

Apps
AI Helps People in War Zones Get Their Voices Heard by Leaders
ai tool for peacekeeping
Apps
AI Helps People in War Zones Get Their Voices Heard by Leaders
The United Nations is using an AI tool to survey people living in war zones, giving them a voice during peacekeeping operations.

The United Nations is using an AI tool to survey people living in war zones, giving them a voice during peacekeeping operations.

Veterans
Amputee Veterans Need to Game, So This Engineer Builds New Controllers from Scratch
adaptive controllers
Veterans
Amputee Veterans Need to Game, So This Engineer Builds New Controllers from Scratch
Inspired by his visits to Walter Reed Medical Center, engineer Ken Jones makes adaptive controllers to keep veterans gaming.

Inspired by his visits to Walter Reed Medical Center, engineer Ken Jones makes adaptive controllers to keep veterans gaming.

AI
Robot Lawyer Helps People Connect With Incarcerated Loved Ones
Robot Lawyer
AI
Robot Lawyer Helps People Connect With Incarcerated Loved Ones
DoNotPay’s robot lawyer can now help people write and send letters to inmates without worrying about violating a facility’s mail rules.

DoNotPay’s robot lawyer can now help people write and send letters to inmates without worrying about violating a facility’s mail rules.

Astronomy
Massive 3D Map of the Universe Fills in “Troublesome” Gap
Map of the Universe
Astronomy
Massive 3D Map of the Universe Fills in “Troublesome” Gap
The Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) has released the largest 3D map of the universe ever created, detailing 11 billion years that were previously uncharted.

The Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) has released the largest 3D map of the universe ever created, detailing 11 billion years that were previously uncharted.

Dispatches
"Cybersecurity for Plants" Can Stop Germs from Hacking Our Food Supply
Dispatches
"Cybersecurity for Plants" Can Stop Germs from Hacking Our Food Supply
Computer hackers exploit flaws in code to access systems and take what they want; plant diseases work the same way.
By John Herlihy

Computer hackers exploit flaws in code to access systems and take what they want; plant diseases work the same way.

Dispatches
The Cause (and Possible Cure) for Most Infertility
The Cause (and Possible Cure) for Most Infertility
Dispatches
The Cause (and Possible Cure) for Most Infertility
Fertility medicine may be on the edge of a breakthrough.

Fertility medicine may be on the edge of a breakthrough.

Superhuman
The Experimental Procedure That Can Reverse Blindness
The Experimental Procedure That Can Reverse Blindness
Superhuman
The Experimental Procedure That Can Reverse Blindness
Doctors told Vanna she was permanently blind. But thanks to an experimental procedure, she can see.
By Mike Riggs

Doctors told Vanna she was permanently blind. But thanks to an experimental procedure, she can see.