Skip to main content
Move the World.

Since the 1980s, an American man named Dennis Hope has been selling plots of land on the moon. As of 2013, Hope claimed to have sold 611 million acres of lunar real estate, at a pre-tax price of $19.95 per acre. His argument--dismissed by space law experts many times over the years--is that international treaties prohibiting any country from owning the moon don’t apply to individuals. So Hope made his claim and then started selling deeds.

Profiles of Hope make for entertaining reading. But they also raise an interesting question: If he doesn’t own the moon, who does? And if no one does, who gets to decide what happens there?

“We’re nowhere near being ready to live on the moon,” you might be thinking. And you would be right! But we’re probably very close to being ready to extract resources from the moon, which means we need rules.

What are the rules of outer space right now?

In 1967, the United Nations passed the Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies; today we refer to it as just the Outer Space Treaty. The agreement has been signed and ratified by 104 countries, and it was mostly intended to keep the United States and the Soviet Union from turning outer space into a battlefield.

07-l
The UN Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space meets in 1963 (Photo via UN)

As such, the treaty has little to say about who can make money off natural resources in outer space. In fact, there’s only one paragraph that speaks to that concern. It says, “Outer space, including the moon and other celestial bodies, is not subject to national appropriation by claim of sovereignty, by means of use or occupation, or by any other means.”

So, no one can own anything in space?

It depends on who you ask. The language in the Outer Space Treaty says no country can exclusively claim any celestial body, but it doesn’t explicitly prohibit countries or commercial actors from selling things--like minerals--obtained in space. It also doesn’t say they can.

Enter the U.S. Government: In 2015, both houses of Congress passed, and President Barack Obama signed, the U.S. Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act. The law covers a number of issues, but the most buzzworthy provision is this paragraph:

"A United States citizen engaged in commercial recovery of an asteroid resource or a space resource under this chapter shall be entitled to any asteroid resource or space resource obtained, including to possess, own, transport, use, and sell the asteroid resource or space resource obtained in accordance with applicable law, including the international obligations of the United States."

In effect, the U.S. declared that while Americans can’t claim ownership of planetary bodies, they can keep (and sell) what they find on those bodies.

In effect, the U.S. declared that while Americans can’t claim ownership of planetary bodies, they can keep (and sell) what they find on those bodies.

What happens if other countries don’t want U.S. companies mining the moon?

That’s the big question space law advocates are mulling over. The Outer Space Treaty was an easy pass largely because the world was more interested in preventing the Cold War from leaking into space than establishing rules for minerals rights. Humans just weren’t ready for space mining in 1967, but the U.S. and the U.S.S.R. were ready for war.

But U.S.-based space companies are optimistic that the law won’t lead to international umbrage. For one thing, there’s a lot of moon to go around, and more than 150 million asteroids in the inner solar system. That means the number of places from whence we can extract resources vastly outnumber our species’ collective ability to extract them.

468195main_4_closest_approach_full
Asteroid Lutetia (Photo via NASA)

At the same time, the U.S. Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act doesn’t prohibit other countries from passing their own resource laws, and there’s no reason to think the U.S. would object if they did. Bob Richards, the CEO of lunar mining company Moon Express, thinks the act is a first step to establish normal, peaceful mining policies that every country could adopt.

"The more that the world agrees that this is OK, the more that we have a chance to be a mature and responsible spacefaring species," Richards told Space News in 2015. "It really is a chance for us, as humans, to find a way to conquer a new frontier without conquering each other. It's a new opportunity for us to try to get things right."

What about colonization? And the rest of space?

Good questions, but the answers are far less clear. The Outer Space Treaty says no country can claim sovereignty, which makes colonizing Mars a murky proposition (and not just because we don’t currently have a viable way to do it).

One proposal is likely to make potential Mars settlers a bit nervous: Let the settlers figure it out on their own.

One proposal is likely to make potential Mars settlers a bit nervous: Let the settlers figure it out on their own.

“Rather than extend the ideas of the parent nation, corporation, or global order, colonists arriving on a liberated Mars would relinquish their former status as earthlings and embrace a new planetary citizenship as martians,” Jacob Haqq-Misra proposed in the Boston Globe last year.

Such an approach would require Mars settlers to “fend for themselves to develop their own systems of conflict resolution, governance, currency, education, art, music, and spirituality — without depending upon any of the legal protections of Earth.”

21424800115_b916921705_k
SpaceX is among those who want to colonize Mars (Photo via SpaceX)

It would also be a tougher sell to the Earth’s governments, which currently operate under the mutual understanding that countries are responsible for what their citizens do in space.

It sounds like there are no solid answers to any of these questions

You are not wrong. But there is a general belief among space advocates that settling the solar system should be done with an eye toward peace and cooperation.

“As a civilized species, we should think about how not to do what we did in the 14th and 15th centuries,” Dr. Ram S. Jakhu, director of the Institute of Air and Space Law at McGill University told me on a recent phone call.

“Europe went to new places, killed people, and destroyed the environment. But that was in keeping with what our species did 500 years ago. Are we more civilized now? We must have a different thinking for exploring space than we did for exploring our own planet.”

Fingers crossed.

Up Next

Future Forward
Reversing Extinction for the Northern White Rhino
Reversing Extinction for the Northern White Rhino
Watch Now
Future Forward
Reversing Extinction for the Northern White Rhino
The Northern white rhino is functionally extinct, meaning the two living females of the species are infertile. This scientist from the San Diego Zoo may have the solution to save the last of this extinct species, by tapping into her frozen zoo.
Watch Now

The Northern White Rhino is functionally extinct - but scientists at the San Diego Zoo are launching an unprecedented effort to recreate the species and save it from extinction. The earth is undergoing an unprecedented wave of extinctions, with estimates that between 200 and 2,000 species go extinct every day. One on the brink is the Northern White Rhinoceros, which after waves of poaching only has two known members in the...

Reverse Innovation
MacGyver Medicine Can Save Lives
MacGyver Medicine Can Save Lives
Reverse Innovation
MacGyver Medicine Can Save Lives
The package is simple and dirt-cheap—a plastic bag with a condom, a syringe, a rubber tube, and a card with...

The package is simple and dirt-cheap—a plastic bag with a condom, a syringe, a rubber tube, and a card with instructions—but it can mean the difference between a mother living and dying.

What Is Cystic Fibrosis—And What Is It Like?
What Is Cystic Fibrosis—And What Is It Like?
What Is Cystic Fibrosis—And What Is It Like?
What you need to know about this genetic disease, explained by someone who knows it inside and out.
By Ella Balasa

What you need to know about this genetic disease, explained by someone who knows it inside and out.

Dispatches
Can DIY Science (Finally) Cut the Cost of Insulin?
Can DIY Science (Finally) Cut the Cost of Insulin?
Dispatches
Can DIY Science (Finally) Cut the Cost of Insulin?
A century after its discovery, insulin is still incredibly expensive, but DIY bio-manufacturing could change that...

A century after its discovery, insulin is still incredibly expensive, but DIY bio-manufacturing could change that in a big way.

The Smartwatch That Could Save Lives
The Smartwatch That Could Save Lives
Watch Now
The Smartwatch That Could Save Lives
Epilepsy can be a scary and dangerous condition. Could this seizure-detecting smartwatch provide peace of mind and save lives?
Watch Now

A start-up called Empatica has created a watch that can sense when an epileptic user is having a seizure. The device will then send the data to the individual's smart phone, which in turn will notify a pre-selected caregiver via phone call or SMS message. Having someone on call at all times to assist an individual with epilepsy can be incredibly comforting to that person and can even save his or her life. Additionally, the...

Can Sleep Deprivation Cure Depression?
Can Sleep Deprivation Cure Depression?
Watch Now
Can Sleep Deprivation Cure Depression?
Losing sleep can have a lot of adverse health effects, but recent science shows it could also have a surprising upside
Watch Now

Studies show that loss of sleep can lead to memory loss, compromised immunity, weight gain, and mood swings. However, scientists are now finding that sleep deprivation may be used to treat depression. Losing sleep has the opposite effect on those struggling with depression. It restores the circadian rhythm that is usually flat in depressed people and it helps balance the parts of the brain that regulate mood. Unfortunately,...

Coded
Hacker Wins Election As Pirate Party Leader
Hacker Wins Election As Pirate Party Leader
Watch Now
Coded
Hacker Wins Election As Pirate Party Leader
Iceland's Pirate Party is trying to use a hacker mindset to improve their country and the world.
Watch Now

In the wake of the Panama Papers hacking scandal, computer programmer Smári McCarthy decided he needed to apply his "hacking for good" philosophy to politics. As a member of the Pirate Party - a political party formed around the concept of extreme transparency - Smári was elected to Parliament in Iceland and is trying to use a hacker mindset to improve his country and the world.

A Lay Person's Guide to Biohacking
A Lay Person's Guide to Biohacking
A Lay Person's Guide to Biohacking
We're living in a golden age of people exploring high and low tech methods to optimize our bodies.
By Mike Riggs

We're living in a golden age of people exploring high and low tech methods to optimize our bodies.

Superhuman
Is the Miracle Medicine of the Future About to Become the Totally Real Medicine of...
Is the Miracle Medicine of the Future About to Become the Totally Real Medicine of the Present?
Superhuman
Is the Miracle Medicine of the Future About to Become the Totally Real Medicine of...
Gene therapy uses a virus to replace missing or defective genes. It sounds counterintuitive, but it could be the...
By Mike Riggs

Gene therapy uses a virus to replace missing or defective genes. It sounds counterintuitive, but it could be the key to curing previously incurable diseases.