Skip to main content
Move the World.

Most people would claim to know the difference between right and wrong, and believe they have the ability to intuitively make good decisions, but how can we be sure that our moral compass is truly pointing us in the right direction, especially when others stand opposed to us?

In what is now a global community in the information age, the bounds and structure of morality are stretched to encompass far more interactions than ever before. On social media, for example, we're often exposed to a diverse array of friends, relatives, acquaintances, and strangers with conflicting moral codes.

Although we might believe that our own moral principles are unwavering, we typically don't apply them objectively across the actions of both loved ones and strangers. We might also weigh them differently for those in close proximity to us, versus those who are thousands of miles away. This begs the question: what is morality, and is it subjective? 

How is a Moral Compass Formed?

Morality can be defined as a code of conduct set forth by a group which is accepted by someone as a guiding principle. Governments, religious groups, and other organizations throughout history have set forth these codes of conduct intended to guide people toward their perception of moral correctness.

Many groups share a common set of essential pillars of morality, such as – don't kill, steal, cheat, or lie. However, these principles are often applied differently based on one's relationship with the guilty party.

If someone hears that a stranger committed adultery, disapproval would be a typical response. But if the person who committed adultery was their brother, whose marriage had been strained for some time, the response might be more forgiving and even empathetic. These intricacies of morality are, in part, what fuel the study of moral psychology.

Moral psychology examines the origination and development of human morality and seeks to gain a better understanding of how humans make decisions. Dr. Liane Young, an associate professor of psychology at Boston College, believes the study of moral psychology could have a profound impact on how humans interact with each other.

If we could better understand the different sources of morality, perhaps we could begin working toward a society built on empathy. "Studying moral psychology allows us access to others' perspectives," Dr. Young explains. "Knowing that there is this complex space of moral psychology could help us to understand where other people are coming from."

Psychology can also help us analyze our own moral development and personal bias. Underneath all of our moral values is a complex web of external influences and experiences that shape who we are today. To truly understand our moral compass, it is important to learn exactly how it found "north."

The Evolution of Morality 

Because a friend who commits a moral crime will likely be judged differently than a stranger, it seems that moral reasoning depends largely on context. Dr. Young and other moral psychologists believe that this subjectivism is due to a practical survival mechanism built into human beings to help them exist within their communities.

Biases can influence peoples' moral compass in a pragmatic sense. In a hunter-gatherer society in which members of a group had to rely on each other, focusing on the wellness of the group as a whole and ensuring that all members treated each other with empathy was necessary for long-term survival.

Underneath all of our moral values is a complex web of external influences and experiences.

In this sense, biases served to improve cooperation within a group as members worked toward a common goal and sometimes, looking past amoral behaviors in the short-term could help maintain unity in the long run.

Charles Darwin was an early advocate of the theory that human morality evolved for survival purposes. He believed that man's capacity for creating moral rules, and ramifications for breaking them, served to distinguish mankind from its nearest relatives in the animal kingdom. In order to survive natural selection, mankind developed a capacity for social interaction and effective collaboration.

Evolutionary theory provides that humans evolved into social beings out of necessity. Humans diverged from their chimpanzee counterparts, who almost solely ate alone, in order to hunt in packs and more successfully gather their own food together. What began as a means of collaborative survival evolved into the codependent societies we have today.

Just as the first human beings had to rely on each other for food and may have had to make moral concessions for the good of the group, modern mankind relies upon collaboration and socialization in the 21st century. 

Applying the Psychology 

The globalization of society has made it so that we are interconnected with more people in more ways than ever before. While we might continue to make subjective decisions for the good of our "tribe," recognizing that our moral compass evolved with a biological purpose may help us to rethink how we judge those outside of our circle.

"Understanding that there are competing moral values that are driving your judgment versus someone else’s judgment can help you to see the other side."

Dr. Liane Young

We can all agree that certain morals are fundamental in a civilized society, but perhaps we can also recognize that not every single moral we individually hold is universal. Then, instead of defaulting to harsh judgments when we believe a stranger has committed an injustice, we can approach them with the same empathy we would extend to a loved one.

"The greater goal is to do something with that understanding of human moral psychology and to bring people together," Dr. Young says. "Understanding that there are competing moral values that are driving your judgment versus someone else's judgment can help you to see the other side."

For more interesting news about the people and ideas that are changing our world, subscribe to Freethink.

Up Next

AI & Ethics
"Moral Machine" Picks Up On Human Ethics
Moral Machine
AI & Ethics
"Moral Machine" Picks Up On Human Ethics
By feeding an AI a diet of books, news articles, and religious texts, researchers were able to create a “moral machine” reflecting the ethics of a society.

By feeding an AI a diet of books, news articles, and religious texts, researchers were able to create a “moral machine” reflecting the ethics of a society.

Father's Day
This Gang is Breaking the Stereotype of the Absent Black Father
the dad gang
Father's Day
This Gang is Breaking the Stereotype of the Absent Black Father
These dads are on a mission to change the way the world views black parenthood.

These dads are on a mission to change the way the world views black parenthood.

#FIXINGJUSTICE - policing
Seeking Justice for George Floyd
George Floyd
#FIXINGJUSTICE - policing
Seeking Justice for George Floyd
Articles, thought leaders, and organizations worth paying attention to following the murder of George Floyd by police in Minnesota.

Articles, thought leaders, and organizations worth paying attention to following the murder of George Floyd by police in Minnesota.

Catalysts
Stopping Gang Violence with Love
Stopping Gang Violence with Love
Watch Now
Catalysts
Stopping Gang Violence with Love
This nonprofit is doing the impossible - finding the 10% of gang members responsible for 90% of the crime, and leading them to successful, positive lives.
Watch Now

“Society gave up on us” - but this community didn’t. Meet UTEC, the organization breaking the cycle of recidivism by helping hardened previously imprisoned gang members walk a better path in Lowell, Massachusetts. UTEC - or United Teen Equality Center - is a non-profit dedicated to stopping gang violence. Obviously, it’s not easy - in Lowell, MA there are over 25 gangs operating, and many gang members have been in prison...

#fixingjustice - Re-entry
The Ride Home from Prison
The Ride Home from Prison
#fixingjustice - Re-entry
The Ride Home from Prison
The "Ride Home Program" sends drivers to pick up former inmates on their first day of freedom to help ensure a...

The "Ride Home Program" sends drivers to pick up former inmates on their first day of freedom to help ensure a smooth transition in those first few critical hours.

Why Prisons are Showing Nature Videos to Inmates
Why Prisons are Showing Nature Videos to Inmates
Watch Now
Why Prisons are Showing Nature Videos to Inmates
Watching nature videos in the unlikeliest of places
Watch Now

At a maximum security prison in Oregon, select inmates watched 60 minutes of nature videos every day for a year. Inspired by the research of Dr. Nalini Nadkarni, the study was intended to measure the psychological benefits of exposure to nature. The results were incredible. Nearly half the inmates said the images soothed them, while violent acts in the prison dropped by 26%. Additionally, guards reported the inmates...

Crossing The Divide
Where Muslims and Jews Worship Together
Where Muslims and Jews Worship Together
Watch Now
Crossing The Divide
Where Muslims and Jews Worship Together
When a Jewish community lost its place of worship, help came from an unexpected place.
Watch Now

When an imam invited a Jewish congregation to worship in his mosque, many of his members left in protest. But the initial controversy has since given way to an inspiring example of tolerance and compassion.