Skip to main content
Move the World.
clinical signs darker skin

Lead Image Courtesy of St. George's University of London

Doctors can learn a lot about a patient's health just by looking at their skin. Red rash on their face? That's a symptom of lupus. Blue lips? Might want to test them for heart disease.

But while learning about these clinical signs of disease during his second year of med school, 20-year-old student Malone Mukwende found himself repeatedly asking the same question:

"But what will it look like on darker skin?"

The problem was that his curriculum at St George's Hospital Medical School often only showed pictures of what symptoms would look like on white skin. The language used to describe skin symptoms also defaulted to their appearance on white patients.

So Mukwende, collaborating with two of his school's lecturers, decided to write a guidebook focused specifically on identifying and describing clinical signs on darker skin.

Mind the Gap

In "Mind the Gap: A Handbook of Clinical Signs in Black and Brown Skin," readers will find side-by-side images of the same illness symptoms on white and darker skin.

In some cases, the difference between the two images can be profound — and doctors not knowing they exist could be potentially deadly for patients.

For example, the rare Kawasaki disease — recently found to be a complication of COVID-19 — causes a bright red rash on white skin. But on darker skin, it looks more "like goose bumps," Mukwende told CBC Radio.

"If both those patients presented to a hospital, we can almost tell that, if there was not this knowledge, who would be getting sent home and who would be receiving treatment," he said. "Consequently, it can mean that someone will end up dying because of that."

This problem of missing clinical signs on darker skin isn't just a hypothetical scenario, either.

In an opinion piece for STAT, dermatology specialist Art Papier describes seeing patients with darker skin suffer due to the same curriculum gap Mukwende hopes to address with his book.

"I've seen patients of color misdiagnosed because clinicians could not recognize their rashes," he wrote. "I've seen immunologic diseases such as lupus, life-threatening drug reactions, and other conditions that manifest themselves on the skin get missed for the same reasons."

Artificial intelligences designed to detect skin conditions are stumbling over the same pitfalls as their human counterparts — because they're trained on image datasets that, like Mukwende's textbooks, are dominated by white skin tones, they're not as adept at spotting signs of disease on darker skin.

A Living Document

Mukwende and his co-authors are now in the process of finding a publisher for the book, but their effort to bridge the curriculum gap won't end when it starts rolling off the presses.

Because they had such a hard time tracking down any photos of some conditions on darker skin, they've decided to launch a companion website for the book where people can send in photos themselves.

"I want it to empower medical professionals."

Malone Mukwende

The authors will include some of those images in future iterations of "Mind the Gap," along with images and descriptions submitted by med students and healthcare workers.

The ultimate goal is for the book to be a "live document" that becomes more useful the longer it exists.

"My hope is that the handbook will become a staple resource in medical settings around the world," Mukwende told the Washington Post. "I want it to empower medical professionals, so they feel more competent, and so patients can be confident that their doctors understand them."

clinical signs darker skin

Malone Mukwende, the 20-year-old medical student behind "Mind the Gap." Credit: Malone Mukwende

We'd love to hear from you! If you have a comment about this article or if you have a tip for a future Freethink story, please email us at [email protected].

Up Next

Health
The Future of Healthcare Could Look a Lot Like the 1900s
The Future of Healthcare Could Look a Lot Like the 1900s
Health
The Future of Healthcare Could Look a Lot Like the 1900s
For many cancer patients, being treated at home is just as safe, more affordable, and more convenient than being...

For many cancer patients, being treated at home is just as safe, more affordable, and more convenient than being treated in a clinical setting.

Superhuman
Three Women Who Changed the Way We Think About Medicine
Three Women Who Changed the Way We Think About Medicine
Superhuman
Three Women Who Changed the Way We Think About Medicine
From newborn health to AIDS treatment to DNA research, these brilliant women paved the way for incredible advances...
By Mike Riggs

From newborn health to AIDS treatment to DNA research, these brilliant women paved the way for incredible advances in the field of medicine.

On the Cusp
How Virtual Reality is Changing Medicine
How Virtual Reality is Changing Medicine
On the Cusp
How Virtual Reality is Changing Medicine
From virtual hearts to immersive battlefields, doctors and scientists are using virtual reality to transform medicine
By Brandon Stewart

From virtual hearts to immersive battlefields, doctors and scientists are using virtual reality to transform medicine

Innovation
In the US, Rural Hospitals Are Closing. Can Medical Drones Fill This Healthcare Gap?
In the US, Rural Hospitals Are Closing. Can Medical Drones Fill This Healthcare Gap?
Innovation
In the US, Rural Hospitals Are Closing. Can Medical Drones Fill This Healthcare Gap?
“Whether you live in the developed world or the developing world, the further you travel outside of a major city,...
By Kaitlin Ugolik

“Whether you live in the developed world or the developing world, the further you travel outside of a major city, the harder it is for you to access the medicine you need to stay healthy and alive.”

Future of Education
Engageli Challenges Zoom for Best Virtual Classroom
Engageli Challenges Zoom for Best Virtual Classroom
Future of Education
Engageli Challenges Zoom for Best Virtual Classroom
Engageli, a new digital education platform launched this week, to provide a solution to remote learning woes.

Engageli, a new digital education platform launched this week, to provide a solution to remote learning woes.

Sustainable Solutions
In a Circular Economy, Leaders Look to Eliminate Waste
In a Circular Economy, Leaders Look to Eliminate Waste
Sustainable Solutions
In a Circular Economy, Leaders Look to Eliminate Waste
A step further than recycling, a circular economy would eliminate the idea of garbage completely. But will consumers hop on board? We gave it a try, and here's our honest review.

A step further than recycling, a circular economy would eliminate the idea of garbage completely. But will consumers hop on board? We gave it a try, and here's our honest review.

Karen Aiach on Doing the Impossible
Karen Aiach on Doing the Impossible
Watch Now
Karen Aiach on Doing the Impossible
When Karen Aiach decided to quit her finance job in 2005 in order to find a cure for the rare genetic disease that...
Watch Now

When Karen Aiach decided to quit her finance job in 2005 in order to find a cure for the rare genetic disease that was killing her daughter, people told her it was impossible. In a weird way, it was just what Karen needed to hear. Because it meant if she didn’t do it, no one else would. She started with a search. The first thing she learned is that her daughter’s disease--a rare metabolic disorder called Sanfilippo...