Skip to main content
Move the World.
How Police Spend Their Time

Lead Image © Peter Kim / Adobe Stock

Using publicly available data, the New York Times has broken down how police spend their time during a typical shift.

Following the death of George Floyd and subsequent police brutality protests, many citizens have begun to rethink the role of law enforcement and what police should be doing. This information could help cities decide where "unbundling the police" might make sense.

How Police Spend Their Time

To determine how police spend their time, the NYT analyzed "calls to service" data from ten U.S. cities.

This data included tripped burglar alarms, calls from citizens to 911 or non-emergency police lines, and radio calls from officers themselves — basically any call that resulted in the dispatching of police.

The data showed that only 1% of all calls to the ten agencies in 2020 were for serious violent crimes (homicides, robberies, rapes, or aggravated assaults).

The NYT acknowledged that this is far from a perfect way to determine how police spend their time, as it doesn't reveal how long officers spend on each call.

To dig a little deeper into that, the newspaper looked into calls with known start and end times in three places: New Orleans, Sacramento, and Montgomery County, MD.

Again, the data suggests that officers spend relatively little time responding to major violent crimes: 4%, 3.7% and 4.1% in the three locations, respectively.

So, if police officers are only spending a small portion of their time responding to serious violent crimes, what are they doing?

In the three locations with start and end times available, police spent an average of 50% of their time responding to either noncriminal calls (35%) or traffic incidents (15%).

This raises the question: are armed officers really the best people to be responding to those types of calls? Proponents of "unbundling the police" would argue that they aren't.

Unbundling the Police

Right now, the U.S. relies on armed law enforcement officers to handle everything from traffic stops to murder investigations.

The basic idea behind "unbundling the police" is that the government officials should narrow the scope of officers' duties. They should then pivot some police funding to groups better suited to handle tasks that used to fall under law enforcement's purview.

Two areas that regularly come up in "unbundling the police" conversations happen to be the same ones the NYT found take up a large portion of officers' days: traffic incidents and noncriminal calls.

"Many of the police homicides, such as the killing of Philando Castile happened at ordinary traffic stops," economist Alex Tabarrock wrote in a Marginal Revolution blog post focused on unbundling. "But why do we need armed men (mostly) to issue a traffic citation?"

"The responsibility for handing out speeding tickets and citations should be handled by an unarmed agency," he suggested. "Put the safety patrol in bright yellow cars and have them carry a bit of extra gasoline and jumper cables to help stranded motorists as part of their job — make road safety nice."

Noncriminal calls, meanwhile, are another target of "unbundling the police" efforts.

Rather than sending armed officers to deal with nonviolent domestic disturbances, neighbor disputes, or issues involving the homeless or mentally ill, we should be sending social workers or people trained in crisis intervention, some argue.

There's even a precedent for this type of response: for 30 years, teams of medics and unarmed crisis workers have been effectively handling public safety calls for police in Eugene, Oregon, through the CAHOOTS (Crisis Assistance Helping Out On The Street) nonprofit.

Some cities are now starting to follow Eugene's lead.

On June 11, San Francisco's mayor announced a police reform plan that would take noncriminal calls off law enforcement's plate, and Portland is rerouting $5 million from its police bureau's budget to a new CAHOOTS-inspired program.

Knowing how police spend their time could help other cities determine how to make their own changes, pivoting resources away from armed officers and toward their replacements — leaving police free to focus solely on those tasks that they are best equipped to handle.

We'd love to hear from you! If you have a comment about this article or if you have a tip for a future Freethink story, please email us at [email protected].

Up Next

#fixingjustice - Policing
Do We Need More Police Or Better Police?
Do We Need More Police Or Better Police?
#fixingjustice - Policing
Do We Need More Police Or Better Police?
American cities are safer than they used to be, but they’re still quite violent, and many economists think they’re...

American cities are safer than they used to be, but they’re still quite violent, and many economists think they’re under-policed. More police could help reduce crime, but only if people trust them to do a good job.

#fixingjustice - Policing
Civilian Oversight Is a Solution to Police Misconduct. But is it Effective?
civilian oversight
#fixingjustice - Policing
Civilian Oversight Is a Solution to Police Misconduct. But is it Effective?
Creating a civilian review board to oversee police conduct seems like a straightforward solution to disciplinary...
By Andrew Denney

Creating a civilian review board to oversee police conduct seems like a straightforward solution to disciplinary issues on the force. But why is it so hard to implement?

Fixing Justice
Rethinking Public Safety: Are Police Always Needed?
Public Safety
Fixing Justice
Rethinking Public Safety: Are Police Always Needed?
The mobile mental health service CAHOOTS handles public safety calls related to mental or behavioral health for the Eugene Police Department.

The mobile mental health service CAHOOTS handles public safety calls related to mental or behavioral health for the Eugene Police Department.

Fixing Justice
Do Police De-Escalation Techniques Work?
de-escalation
Fixing Justice
Do Police De-Escalation Techniques Work?
The public is calling on law enforcement to find alternatives to using force. But do de-escalation tactics actually work?

The public is calling on law enforcement to find alternatives to using force. But do de-escalation tactics actually work?

Fixing Justice
Your Smartphone Can Help End Police Misconduct
Police Misconduct
Fixing Justice
Your Smartphone Can Help End Police Misconduct
There are now apps, websites, and phone shortcuts designed to help you not only document police misconduct, but also report and protect it.

There are now apps, websites, and phone shortcuts designed to help you not only document police misconduct, but also report and protect it.

#fixingjustice - policing
The Dad Changing How Police Shootings Are Investigated
The Dad Changing How Police Shootings Are Investigated
Watch Now
#fixingjustice - policing
The Dad Changing How Police Shootings Are Investigated
After his son was killed by police, Michael Bell fought for over a decade to change how we investigate police shootings.
Watch Now

For over a decade, ever since police killed his son, Michael Bell has been trying to get an independent investigation into the shooting — and he's fighting to make sure that every family is entitled to one, whenever police use lethal force. In November 2004, his son, Michael Bell, Jr., was pulled over in front of his home in Kenosha, Wisconsin, for an alleged traffic violation. Although a dashcam video captures the initial...

#FIXINGJUSTICE - policing
Independent Watchdog Invisible Institute Helps Police Accountability
How to Hold Police Accountable
Watch Now
#FIXINGJUSTICE - policing
Independent Watchdog Invisible Institute Helps Police Accountability
The Invisible Institute is making Chicago police complaints easily available to the public—and is helping hold police accountable.
Watch Now

A Freethink update: It's been several months since we first brought you the story of journalist Jamie Kalven and his influential "Sixteen Shots" expose in Slate that depicted a corrupt Chicago police department in the midst of a cover-up following the racist killing of teenager Laquan McDonald, who was shot 16 times by Officer Jason Van Dyke on October 20, 2014. Since then, Kalven has written another critical piece, this...

Fixing Justice
Volunteers Build First Nationwide Database of Police Records
Police Records
Fixing Justice
Volunteers Build First Nationwide Database of Police Records
Thousands of volunteers are data scraping public websites to compile police records into a single national database for researchers to mine.

Thousands of volunteers are data scraping public websites to compile police records into a single national database for researchers to mine.