Skip to main content
Move the World.
Ventilators for COVID-19

Lead Image © Phonlamai Photo / Adobe Stock

A newly published study suggests that we may not need as many ventilators for COVID-19 patients as previously expected.

The reasoning? Many patients who fit the current criteria for invasive ventilation might actually have a better shot of beating COVID-19 without it.

Using Ventilators for COVID-19 Patients

If a person with a respiratory illness is no longer able to breathe on their own, a ventilator can pump air directly into their lungs through a tube inserted down their throats.

But this tube can give viruses a way into the lungs, and if the incoming air pressure is too high, it can damage the organs, making ventilator use risky.

While ventilators are risky in general, COVID-19 patients seem to respond particularly poorly to the devices.

For some people with severe cases of the coronavirus, it's a risk absolutely worth taking.

However, according to the new study published in the American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, healthcare workers may be overusing ventilators for COVID-19 patients.

At the core of the issue is the use of low blood oxygen levels (hypoxemia) as a criteria for mechanical ventilation.

A normal blood oxygen level is between 95% and 100%. If a patient hits 93%, standard practice is to treat them with a noninvasive device, such as a continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) machine or bilevel positive airway pressure (BiPAP) machine.

Both of those devices deliver oxygen via a mask, but if they can't raise a patient's blood oxygen level, the next step, by the book, is to sedate the patient and place them on a mechanical ventilator.

Keeping Coronavirus Patients Alive

By the time a typical patient with pneumonia or sepsis reaches the point that they need a ventilator, they're gasping for air.

But doctors have reported far different observations with coronavirus patients — some are still able to speak in full sentences and show little to no signs of respiratory distress, even as their blood oxygen levels drop below 80% and doctors set out to intubate them.

According to the authors of the new study, this suggests that healthcare workers shouldn't use blood oxygen levels as the sole determining factor for using ventilators for COVID-19, instead focusing more on the patient's respiratory distress or fatigue levels.

One immediately obvious benefit of this is that there should be more ventilators for COVID-19 patients to go around, meaning fears of future shortages might never come to fruition.

But there's also a secondary potential benefit: we might see an improvement in coronavirus mortality.

Rethinking Ventilator Usage

While ventilators are risky in general, COVID-19 patients seem to respond particularly poorly to the devices.

A recent study in JAMA of more than 2,600 COVID-19 patients in New York found that 88% of those placed on ventilators died — far higher than the average of 40% to 50% for other respiratory illnesses.

Ventilators should be the last step along a progression of oxygen treatments.

That apparently poor track record could be explained by the fact that only the very sickest people are placed on ventilators in the first place, or it could be that ventilators are ineffective or counterproductive for many patients.

While the team behind that study conceded that it's impossible to know whether those patients might have lived had they not been placed on ventilators, the recent findings have healthcare workers at the highest level rethinking the machines' role in fighting the COVID-19 pandemic.

On April 21, the National Institute of Health (NIH) released guidelines for treating COVID-19 patients, and it recommends that medical staff approach ventilators as the last step along a progression of oxygen treatments.

First, they should deliver oxygen via a high-flow nasal cannula. If that doesn't help, the NIH recommends trying a positive-pressure device, and only turning to a ventilator for COVID-19 patients as a last resort.

Up Next

If you want to understand a problem, talk to the people working on solutions. Join us as we meet the people and explore the ideas on the frontlines of an unprecedented global response.

Public Health
Researchers Unveil Low-Cost Coronavirus Ventilator Design
coronavirus ventilator
Public Health
Researchers Unveil Low-Cost Coronavirus Ventilator Design
Researchers have specifically designed a new coronavirus ventilator to address the critical shortage caused by the abundance of COVID-19 patients.

Researchers have specifically designed a new coronavirus ventilator to address the critical shortage caused by the abundance of COVID-19 patients.

Medical Innovation
Ford Revs Up Production of Coronavirus Ventilators
coronavirus ventilators
Medical Innovation
Ford Revs Up Production of Coronavirus Ventilators
Ford has promised to deliver 50,000 ventilators in 100 days. Here's how they can do it.
By Alex Cardinale

Ford has promised to deliver 50,000 ventilators in 100 days. Here's how they can do it.

Public Health
Silicon Valley Fixes Broken Ventilators for Coronavirus Patients
Ventilators for Coronavirus Patients
Public Health
Silicon Valley Fixes Broken Ventilators for Coronavirus Patients
Silicon Valley-based Bloom Energy has refurbished hundreds of ventilators for coronavirus patients in just a few weeks — and it shows no signs of slowing down.

Silicon Valley-based Bloom Energy has refurbished hundreds of ventilators for coronavirus patients in just a few weeks — and it shows no signs of slowing down.

Public Health
Doctors Use AI to Test New Coronavirus Treatments on Patients
Coronavirus Treatments
Public Health
Doctors Use AI to Test New Coronavirus Treatments on Patients
The University of Pittsburgh Medical Center launched a new trial that uses artificial intelligence to test promising coronavirus treatments as quickly as possible.

The University of Pittsburgh Medical Center launched a new trial that uses artificial intelligence to test promising coronavirus treatments as quickly as possible.

Public Health
Does a Positive Antibody Test Mean I’m Immune? It Depends.
coronavirus antibody test
Public Health
Does a Positive Antibody Test Mean I’m Immune? It Depends.
As the conversation shifts from tracking and diagnosing COVID-19 to reopening society, people are now focused on antibody tests. But experts warn that an antibody screen may supply a false peace of mind.

As the conversation shifts from tracking and diagnosing COVID-19 to reopening society, people are now focused on antibody tests. But experts warn that an antibody screen may supply a false peace of mind.

Public Health
Why Is an Antigen Test a Big Deal for COVID-19?
Antigen Test
Public Health
Why Is an Antigen Test a Big Deal for COVID-19?
The FDA has issued its first emergency use authorization for a COVID-19 antigen test, a new type of test for diagnosing the coronavirus.

The FDA has issued its first emergency use authorization for a COVID-19 antigen test, a new type of test for diagnosing the coronavirus.

Public Health
Antiviral Pill Shows Promise as Treatment for Coronavirus
Treatment for Coronavirus
Public Health
Antiviral Pill Shows Promise as Treatment for Coronavirus
The oral antiviral drug EIDD-2801 has emerged as a promising treatment for coronavirus, performing well in the lab and in mouse studies.

The oral antiviral drug EIDD-2801 has emerged as a promising treatment for coronavirus, performing well in the lab and in mouse studies.

Public Health
Coronavirus Antibody Testing Project Launches in Colorado
Antibody Testing
Public Health
Coronavirus Antibody Testing Project Launches in Colorado
Colorado’s San Miguel County has launched an antibody testing project to test the blood of all 8,000 residents for signs that they’re immune to COVID-19.

Colorado’s San Miguel County has launched an antibody testing project to test the blood of all 8,000 residents for signs that they’re immune to COVID-19.

Public Health
Doctors: Home-Based Care for Coronavirus Could Save Lives
home-based care for coronavirus
Public Health
Doctors: Home-Based Care for Coronavirus Could Save Lives
A group of doctors in Italy is making the case for more home-based care for coronavirus patients as a way of coping with the overwhelming COVID-19 outbreak.

A group of doctors in Italy is making the case for more home-based care for coronavirus patients as a way of coping with the overwhelming COVID-19 outbreak.