The imagination effect: A history of placebo power

“There are men on whom the mere sight of medicine is operative,” wrote the French philosopher Michel de Montaigne in 1572.

A patient swallows a sugar pill that lacks active medicine, or undergoes “surgery” in which incisions are made but the therapeutic procedure is not performed. And yet pain falls away, nausea recedes, mood lifts. Sometimes, the improvements were going to happen anyway. But other times, what’s at play is the power of the mind to influence the body.

This, the famous placebo effect, has a long, rich history — it certainly had an outsized role in the medicine of centuries past, when useless pills and potions were often all that physicians had to offer. Many among the learned knew what they were dealing with: “There are men on whom the mere sight of medicine is operative,” wrote the French philosopher Michel de Montaigne in 1572.

Perkins tractors, touted as cure-alls, were all the rage at the end of the 18th Century. An early “placebo” trial found they didn’t work. This 1802 caricature shows a society lady being treated with a Perkins tractor to cure her “venomous tongue”. (C. WILLIAMS/WELLCOME COLLECTION (CC BY))

The first scientific demonstration of the placebo effect came in 1799 when a British physician, John Haygarth, set out to test one of the quack remedies on sale at that time: expensive metal rods named Perkins tractors that purported to draw disease from the body. Haygarth pitted these rods against sham, wooden Perkins tractors that looked just the same as the 5-guinea ones on sale, and found that 4 of 5 patients with rheumatism reported that their pain improved. (He published his findings in a book, On the Imagination as a Cause and as a Cure of Disorders of the Body.)

Haygarth did not use the term placebo effect for what he’d seen. Though the word placebo had long been used in other contexts, the term as it’s used today was introduced in a 1920 paper in The LancetPlacebo effect entered clinical vernacular some decades later, after American anesthesiologist Henry K. Beecher observed that some wounded men from the battlefields of World War II often fared well without morphine. Since then, the many studies done on placebo effects show them to be strongest in conditions where perceptions are key, such as pain, anxiety and depression.

At Beecher’s urging, placebos were also put to work in new ways in the modern scientific era: They became mainstays of gold-standard, double-blind clinical trials to better elucidate a medicine’s true effects. In the purest form of such trials, only a subset of study participants receives a substance being tested. The others get a sham substance, and nobody knows who got what till the results are in and the study is “unblinded.” A drug can only be said to work when it outperforms the placebo in a statistically significant manner. (In many modern trials, an experimental treatment is compared against standard of care instead of a placebo, for ethical reasons.)

Of course, the fact that placebos can influence patients’ perceptions and symptoms complicates the matter: It means that a drug being tested has to perform not just better than nothing — it must also best the power of mind over body.

This article originally appeared in Knowable Magazine, a nonprofit publication dedicated to making scientific knowledge accessible to all. Sign up for Knowable Magazine’s newsletter.

Knowable Magazine | Annual Reviews

Related
Gain-of-function research is more than just tweaking risky viruses
Gain-of-function experiments in the lab can help researchers get ahead of viruses naturally gaining the ability to infect people in the wild.
The radical drop in maternal mortality was a public health miracle
In 1758 in Sweden, 1205 mothers died for every 100,000 live births, which was likely representative of the global maternal mortality rate.
Nope, coffee won’t give you extra energy
You might feel like coffee gives you the energy to get through the day – but chances are, you’re not getting as much as you think.
Adult-made neurons mature longer, have unique functions
Neuroscientists don’t know the degree to which adult brains generate new neurons, but adult-made neurons appear to have more “mature” functions.
Chronic pain can be objectively measured using brain signals
Even though pain is universal and we know it happens in the brain, we’ve never before had a way to objectively measure its intensity.
Up Next
Subscribe to Freethink for more great stories