Skip to main content
Move the World.
imagining the future

Lead Image © Vladislav Ociacia / Adobe Stock

When it comes to imagining the future, people are... not great.

Consider the past year: despite the world's long history of devastating pandemics, most of the world had no pandemic preparedness plan.

Or, more lightheartedly, consider what WIRED's Paul Ford found in his copy of 1980's The Book of Predictions. Some, sure, were shockingly close (a prediction about Bitcoin, for instance), but most of the book is "a special, concentrated kind of wrong." The Bitcoin Nostradamus also foresaw Minneapolis becoming America's new national capital by 1999.

Why do we go so wrong when it comes to thinking about the future? What happens at the level of the brain? New research out of the University of Pennsylvania may have illuminated the process behind imagination.

Something during nothing: There's a part of the brain called the default mode network (DMN), and it's working hard at doing nothing. 

"These regions seem to be active when people aren't asked to do anything in particular, as opposed to being asked to do something cognitively," UPenn neuroscientist Joseph Kable told Penn Today.

The DMN has been suspected of playing a role in imagining the future but, as with pretty much anything involving the brain, we don't really know exactly how. While previous research has shown that the DMN also activates when we're imagining events, Kable wanted to get a deeper understanding.

Kable and two of his former grad students, Cal-Berkeley postdoc Sangil Lee and Trishala Parthasarathi, associate director of scientific services at OrtleyBio, used fMRI to attempt to do just that.

A split decision: In their study, published in The Journal of Neuroscience, the team took 24 subjects — 13 female, 11 male — and tasked them with responding to imaginative prompts.

Inside an fMRI machine — which can show where blood is flowing in the brain, a kind of analogue for what parts of the brain are working harder than normal — the subjects had seven seconds to read one of the researcher's 32 different premises, such as "Imagine you're sitting on a warm beach on a tropical island," or "Imagine you win the lottery next year." 

Then, the subjects got 12 seconds to imagine their future, and another 14 seconds to evaluate "vividness and valence." 

Vividness is how detailed you can make your mental image, Kable said — how brightly those details pop in your mind. Valence is the emotional component; is the event positive or negative? Would you look forward with anticipation or dread? 

Everyone went through the process four times, and a split emerged: two different sub-networks of the DMN were activating, one for vividness and one for valence. And not only that, but it seemed like a hard split — they didn't share the work. 

"One network, which we'll call the dorsal default mode network, was influenced by valence," Kable said. "In other words, it was more active for positive events than for negative events, but it was not influenced at all by vividness. It seems to be involved in the evaluative function."

Two different sub-networks of the DMN were activating, one for vividness and one for valence.

In other words, the emotional impact part was separate from the actual imaginating part.

The vividness network wasn't impacted by valence; it was active for both positive and negative events, "showing that network really is involved in the construction piece of imagination."

Exploring the land of pure imagination: Kable believes this work is a first step towards helping us understand imagination. But more nuanced assessments will need to be made to continue teasing out what's likely to be a complex function. 

The lab hopes the insights from this study and future ones can help them understand our relationship with the future; they're already investigating why people seem to undervalue future outcomes compared to one happening immediately. 

"One theory is that the future isn't as vivid, isn't as tangible and detailed and concrete as something right in front of your face," he said. "We've started to use our identification of the sub-network involved in construction to ask the question, how active is this network when people are thinking about future outcomes compared to the same outcome in the present."

With that work ongoing, you can, well, imagine a future where we finally crack the code of why we're such good imaginers and such bad predictors.

We'd love to hear from you! If you have a comment about this article or if you have a tip for a future Freethink story, please email us at [email protected]

Up Next

Neuroscience
Dopamine and Serotonin May Do More Than We Thought
dopamine and serotonin
Neuroscience
Dopamine and Serotonin May Do More Than We Thought
Dopamine and serotonin are crucial brain chemicals. A new study that measured them simultaneously in active brains suggests they may do more than we think.

Dopamine and serotonin are crucial brain chemicals. A new study that measured them simultaneously in active brains suggests they may do more than we think.

Uprising
Diving Deep Into the Brain to Measure Neurotransmitters
Using computation psychiatry to study the brain
Uprising
Diving Deep Into the Brain to Measure Neurotransmitters
Researchers are taking the first measurements of neurotransmitters in active human brains, using computational psychiatry to understand how the mind works.

Researchers are taking the first measurements of neurotransmitters in active human brains, using computational psychiatry to understand how the mind works.

The Brain
Scientists Are Developing Brain Implants That Improve Memory
Brain Implants
The Brain
Scientists Are Developing Brain Implants That Improve Memory
New research sheds hope for sufferers of traumatic brain injury, Alzheimer’s, and for all of us, old age.

New research sheds hope for sufferers of traumatic brain injury, Alzheimer’s, and for all of us, old age.

Virology
One Mosquito Protein Weakens Several Deadly Flaviviruses
Flaviviruses
Virology
One Mosquito Protein Weakens Several Deadly Flaviviruses
A mosquito protein that targets the viral envelope of flaviviruses, inhibiting their activity, could help doctors treat several life-threatening diseases.

A mosquito protein that targets the viral envelope of flaviviruses, inhibiting their activity, could help doctors treat several life-threatening diseases.

The Future Explored
Are Fecal Transplants the Fountain of Youth?
fecal transplants
The Future Explored
Are Fecal Transplants the Fountain of Youth?
Scientists hope that fecal transplants from younger to older people could be used to treat age-related cognitive decline.

Scientists hope that fecal transplants from younger to older people could be used to treat age-related cognitive decline.

Future of Medicine
Will These Lab-Made Viruses Prevent a Pandemic?
gain of function mutation
Future of Medicine
Will These Lab-Made Viruses Prevent a Pandemic?
Previously blacklisted gain-of-function mutation experiments are back, and they’re being used to fight the next major pandemic.

Previously blacklisted gain-of-function mutation experiments are back, and they’re being used to fight the next major pandemic.

Women Leaders
Female Scientists Were Written out of History Books. Margaret Rossiter Changed That.
Female Scientists Were Written out of History Books. Margaret Rossiter Changed That.
Women Leaders
Female Scientists Were Written out of History Books. Margaret Rossiter Changed That.
Margaret Rossiter has made it her lifework to spotlight female scientists who were written out of history books through systematic censorship. Read our Q&A with this groundbreaking historian.

Margaret Rossiter has made it her lifework to spotlight female scientists who were written out of history books through systematic censorship. Read our Q&A with this groundbreaking historian.

Dispatches
New Tech Makes Fresh Produce Last Twice as Long
New Tech Makes Fresh Produce Last Twice as Long
Dispatches
New Tech Makes Fresh Produce Last Twice as Long
The plant-based preservative could radically change the game on food waste.

The plant-based preservative could radically change the game on food waste.

Superhuman
Robotic Wheelchair Revolution
Robotic Wheelchair Revolution
Watch Now
Superhuman
Robotic Wheelchair Revolution
Part Wheelchair. Part Robot. Is this the future of accessibility?
Watch Now

How Rory Cooper Built the Custom Wheelchair When people think about using wheelchairs, they probably don’t envision a custom design. Instead, they picture a bulky frame, handicap ramps, special vans for transportation with archaic wheelchair lifts, and a design out of the past. The sad truth is wheelchair technology has changed very little in the last 200 years. And over time, these dated designs can cause physical injury...