Skip to main content
Move the World.
Meet the Artist Who Paints With DNA Clues

When Maayan Harel paints a portrait, her subject isn't sitting in front of her. She doesn't even have a photograph to work from. Instead, she looks at clues from ancient human DNA.

Last month, scientists from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem made headlines when they revealed Harel's portrait of a Denisovan, an extinct group of archaic humans that may have lived with Neanderthals.

The first Denisovan remains were discovered a decade ago in a Siberian cave. Since then, researchers have collected small fossils – teeth, a jawbone, a finger – but not enough to reconstruct an entire face or body.

So, they looked for clues in the Denisovan DNA. They homed in on epigenetic changes, heritable changes that influence gene activity and how a gene is expressed as a characteristic or trait. The expression of these traits are clues about what one possible Denisovan might look like. Science illustrator, Harel interpreted those clues to create a science-based portrait of the ancient human.

Freethink talked with Harel about the balance of artistic freedom and scientific accuracy.

This interview has been edited and condensed for clarity.

Maayan Harel sculpting the model used for her portrait of a Denisovan human. Photo courtesy of Maayan Harel.

Maayan Harel sculpting the model used for her portrait of a Denisovan human. Photo courtesy of Maayan Harel.

Freethink: How is science illustration different from other portrait art?

Harel: An artist's work is their own interpretation. But this portrait was entirely based on research, plus the artist's interpretation when necessary. I didn't think, "Oh, I want her to look like this." Instead, I thought, "This is what we know, this is how to present what we know. This is the best possible representation."

Even though this is not a picture of an actual Denisovan and this is what she (in particular) looked like, it's the genetic analysis of one specific specimen, so it is based on one Denisovan. But the traits that they found are not individual traits. The results are more generalistic.

Freethink: What was the biggest challenge in creating a portrait based on DNA?

Harel: The biggest challenge was conceiving the whole way to do it. It's a very unusual situation. In most reconstructions, you have a skull to work with. I've never encountered anything like this, and I think it's pretty unusual – figuring out how to work from, basically, an Excel spreadsheet and bring something to life was really challenging.

It's hard to put 3D (on) to 2D, because you have only a certain list of things that are known from the research, so a more appropriate solution was to sculpt. So I sculpted the skull, and then I put it in a dark closet so that I could simulate a cave, and photographed it. Then I painted it digitally in Photoshop.

Science illustrator Maayan Harel's portrait of a Denisovan, an extinct group of ancient humans that may have lived with Neanderthals. Harel interpreted DNA clues to create a science-based portrait. Image courtesy of Maayan Harel.

Science illustrator Maayan Harel's portrait of a Denisovan, an extinct group of ancient humans that may have lived with Neanderthals. Harel interpreted DNA clues to create a science-based portrait. Image courtesy of Maayan Harel.

Freethink: What kind of clues did the researchers provide?

Harel: I got a list of traits. One of the most unique traits is they had very wide parietal bones – the top of their skulls were quite wide. The other is that they had a very large dental arch and large teeth. I had a list of about 50 traits, and the skull was probably two-thirds of that. We knew those few traits about the skull, but we didn't know anything else.

Once we had the sculpture of the skull, it was something that could be worked from. So if I know that the parietal bones are wider, I can expand them by hand. If I know the nose projection is somewhere between this and that, I can kind of adjust it.

Freethink: How accurate is the portrait?

Harel: It's not accurate in the sense that it's one particular girl. This portrait is meant to give a final possible face. Given that Denisovans are genetically very similar to Neanderthals, and there's a lot of evidence that they lived alongside Neanderthals, we decided that anything that was unknown would be assumed (that) the trait is like the Neanderthal.

Part of the problem is, it sounds like you can now tell what a person looks like from their DNA. That's not the case at all. Like modern humans, everyone is an individual. So a lot of effort was actually put into making a Neanderthal profile that would be as generalistic and quintessential and as "this is a Neanderthal" as possible. So, we could say: if we're creating a general Denisovan and we're assuming that what we don't know is generally like Neanderthal, we have a good basis to work from.

Subscribe

Up Next

Coded
Meet the Artist and Activist Who Wants You to Erase Your DNA
Meet the Artist and Activist Who Wants You to Erase Your DNA
Coded
Meet the Artist and Activist Who Wants You to Erase Your DNA
Heather Dewey-Hagborg wants to make sure people understand the hidden secrets in the DNA they leave behind...
By Michael O'Shea

Heather Dewey-Hagborg wants to make sure people understand the hidden secrets in the DNA they leave behind everywhere they go.

Volcanoes
Dropping Drones into Volcanoes Can Help Us Predict Eruptions
predict volcanic eruptions
Volcanoes
Dropping Drones into Volcanoes Can Help Us Predict Eruptions
The ratio of sulphur to carbon dioxide being released can be an indicator of imminent volcanic eruptions. Researchers are using drones to gather that data.

The ratio of sulphur to carbon dioxide being released can be an indicator of imminent volcanic eruptions. Researchers are using drones to gather that data.

Emergency Response
Real-Time Data Can Save Lives in a Disaster
emergency response
Emergency Response
Real-Time Data Can Save Lives in a Disaster
Researchers are working on new algorithms that could provide emergency response managers with real-time data to save more lives.

Researchers are working on new algorithms that could provide emergency response managers with real-time data to save more lives.

The Brain
Scientists Are Developing Brain Implants That Improve Memory
Brain Implants
The Brain
Scientists Are Developing Brain Implants That Improve Memory
New research sheds hope for sufferers of traumatic brain injury, Alzheimer’s, and for all of us, old age.

New research sheds hope for sufferers of traumatic brain injury, Alzheimer’s, and for all of us, old age.

Seachange
Ship’s Logbooks Are the First Records of Climate Change Data
Ship’s Logbooks Are the First Records of Climate Change Data
Seachange
Ship’s Logbooks Are the First Records of Climate Change Data
With the weather and ice data from old ship’s logs, Dr. Kevin Wood realized it was possible to reconstruct the history of sea ice in the Arctic to better understand climate change.

With the weather and ice data from old ship’s logs, Dr. Kevin Wood realized it was possible to reconstruct the history of sea ice in the Arctic to better understand climate change.

Dispatches
Scientists Physically "Transplant" a Memory in Snails
Scientists Physically
Dispatches
Scientists Physically "Transplant" a Memory in Snails
The experiment breaks the conventional wisdom about what memories are made of.

The experiment breaks the conventional wisdom about what memories are made of.

Coded
How AI Could Revolutionize Coffee
How AI Could Revolutionize Coffee
Watch Now
Coded
How AI Could Revolutionize Coffee
Could the blockchain be used to make fair trade goods live up to their promise?
Watch Now

Around 1 in 60 people on the globe rely on the coffee supply chain for their livelihood. But it’s an antiquated system, rife with uncertainty, unfairness, and even corruption. Bext360 wants to change that. They’re using machine vision, artificial intelligence, and blockchain payments to bring the largest un-automated system in the world into the digital age.

Coded
WATCH: Trailer for Our New Show, Coded
WATCH: Trailer for Our New Show, Coded
Coded
WATCH: Trailer for Our New Show, Coded
Meet the programmers on the frontlines of the war over security and privacy.
By Mike Riggs

Meet the programmers on the frontlines of the war over security and privacy.

The New Space Race
Why the U.S. Government Treated Satellites and Machine Guns as the Same for 15 Years
Why the U.S. Government Treated Satellites and Machine Guns as the Same for 15 Years
The New Space Race
Why the U.S. Government Treated Satellites and Machine Guns as the Same for 15 Years
Regulations forced companies that planned to sell satellites to other countries to register, in effect, as arms...
By Jeff Foust

Regulations forced companies that planned to sell satellites to other countries to register, in effect, as arms dealers.